No — reliable evidence indicates Jack Hextall is right-handed.

Jack Hextall (1918-1961) was a Canadian professional ice hockey player who played primarily as a defenceman. He was known for his solid defensive play and contributing to his team's efforts over several seasons in various leagues.

Hextall's professional career included time with teams like the Washington Lions in the Eastern Amateur Hockey League (EAHL) and the Winnipeg Monarchs, among others. He was part of a hockey-playing family, with his grandson Ron Hextall also achieving fame in the sport as an NHL goaltender.

Throughout his career, Jack Hextall was regarded as a reliable presence on the ice. His contributions were often characterized by his steady performance in defensive roles, helping to protect his team's net and transition the puck up the ice.

After his playing career, Hextall remained connected to the hockey world through his family's continued involvement. His legacy is remembered through his family's prominent place in Canadian hockey history.